ZeroHour

Search: “Stephen Aarons”

7 items

Lawyer fined $5K over AI-hallucinated witnesses in a murder case

New Mexico Supreme Court fined lawyer Stephen Aarons $5,000 for filing a murder appeal brief with ChatGPT-fabricated witnesses and testimony.

New Mexico's Supreme Court fined lawyer Stephen Aarons $5,000 and held him in contempt for an appeal brief in a murder conviction case that contained AI-fabricated witnesses and false testimony about the shooter's clothing and appearance. Aarons admitted using ChatGPT and believing it would produce a bulletproof summary of the trial. Justice C. Shannon Bacon questioned how he could be unaware of AI hallucination risks, noting such cases are frequently in the news. The sanction follows other courts fining lawyers for AI-generated fake citations, including two law firms and Mike Lindell's legal team.

ChatGPT-using lawyer punished for citing fake testimony from made-up witnesses

New Mexico Supreme Court holds lawyer in contempt for filing a ChatGPT-generated brief citing fabricated witness testimony; fined $5,000 and referred to disciplinary board.

The New Mexico Supreme Court held criminal defense lawyer Stephen Aarons in direct contempt for filing a murder-appeal brief containing false testimony from wholly fabricated witnesses, including Officer Michelle Amarillo and Officer Sanchez, plus misrepresented legal authority. Aarons admitted feeding a computer-generated trial transcript into ChatGPT, powered by the OpenAI o3 model, and filing the output without verifying factual claims or telling his client. He was fined $5,000, referred to a disciplinary board, and barred from appearing before the court pending proceedings; the court struck all briefs and ordered new counsel for client Oscar Renee Sandoval.

Ars Technica · AIupdated · 5d agofirst · 5d agoAI safety & security 2 sources