Skip to content
NewA calmer, faster ZeroHour
Otherinfo

Essay traces false Islamic invention claims to a Wikipedia editor

Original title: The Invention of Islamic Invention

Hacker News · securityby curtisblaine ()8 min read1
AI summary · x-ai/grok-4.7Summaries by Vani AI

The post says Jagged_85 made more than 87,000 edits from 2005 until being caught in 2012, and some claims later entered scholarship.

A sponsored essay argues that many popular claims about inventions from the Islamic Golden Age were inflated by Wikipedia editor Jagged_85 rather than supported by the cited sources. It says he rarely invented claims outright but stretched citations so lists of known equipment or descriptions of existing processes were presented as discoveries. The author says some of those claims later appeared in scholarly writing because amateur editors could not check offline sources.

Unconfirmed: The account is the author's historical argument, not an independently reported investigation.

Key facts
  • Jagged_85 edited from 2005 until being caught in 2012.
  • The post says he made more than 87,000 edits and vandalized thousands of articles.
  • Cited sources often described use or translation, not invention, the author argues.
  • Distorted claims about Avicennian logic remain online, according to the essay.
Analyze this story with Vani AIImpact, who is affected and what defenders should do, in a new chat

From the original article

8 min read at cremieux.xyz

Today’s post is brought to you by my sponsor, Mechanize . They’re hiring junior software engineers at $300K/year base salary. Growing up, it was a common trope that cultures that we now associate with poverty, violence, and oppression were once world-leading in promoting prosperity and moral progress as well as the quintessentially human act of inventing.

Hacker News · security

By curtisblaine · cremieux.xyz

Read the full article at Hacker News · security

A short excerpt; the article and its images belong to the publisher. Summary, key facts and assessment above are AI-written from the article and can be wrong.