Users report Google Search requiring login on some shared IP addresses
Original title: Tell HN: Google Search to start locking down search behind a login wall
A Hacker News poster says CGNAT addresses now hit a sign-in wall after repeated CAPTCHAs; Google has not confirmed it.
A Hacker News poster says Google Search shows repeated CAPTCHAs on some ISP CGNAT addresses and, more recently, locks results behind a login prompt on some of those IPs. They report not seeing the prompt on some VPN addresses, including a free Firefox VPN. Commenters link the friction to bot traffic and AI scraping and mention similar login prompts elsewhere, but the thread includes no vendor statement.
Unconfirmed: Google has not confirmed a login requirement; the report is one user’s observation.
- The poster says they first saw the login wall today.
- They contrast it with YouTube’s existing “confirm you’re not a bot” sign-in prompt.
- Shared and public computers would be less able to use signed-out search.
- One commenter says ResearchGate also demands login for unusual IP activity.
- Vendors
- Products
- Google Search
From the original article
2 min read at news.ycombinator.com[](https://news. ycombinator. com/)Hacker Newsnew past comments ask show jobs submitlogin [](https://news.
By exploraz · news.ycombinator.com
A short excerpt; the article and its images belong to the publisher. Summary, key facts and assessment above are AI-written from the article and can be wrong.