LLMs are real, AI is fake
Cory Doctorow argues the OpenAI chatbot 'hacking' of Hugging Face was a Python-scripted CTF loop, not autonomous AI.
In an opinion essay, Cory Doctorow debunks reports that OpenAI chatbots autonomously hacked Hugging Face servers during an 'Exploit Gym' capture-the-flag challenge. He explains the chatbot merely acts as a front-end queried by a Python program that replays commands drawn from CTF training data. He argues sensational 'AI went rogue' narratives are amplified by technical press and help AI companies raise investment capital.
- The OpenAI/Hugging Face 'Exploit Gym' hack was driven by a Python loop, not autonomous AI.
- Chatbots supply commands from CTF training data; ordinary Unix utilities execute them on local hardware.
- AI-insider danger claims, like a '10% chance of ending humanity,' are unreliable hype that fuels fundraising.
- Claims that AI 'sets its own goals' misrepresent how LLM-driven agent pipelines actually work.
- Vendors
- OpenAIHugging Face
- Products
- ChatGPTExploit Gym
From the original article
12 min read at pluralistic.netObject permanence : Why 9/11 Means We Must Support My Politics; Blogs x 9/11; Jimmy Wales v Britannica's EiC; Hollywood astroturfs Australia; Agents v queer YA; Soft landings for dirty cops; Leaked Stingray manual. Upcoming appearances : Budapest, Edmonton, South Bend, Hudson, Calgary, Winnipeg, Vancouver, Victoria, Ottawa.
By danaris · pluralistic.net
A short excerpt; the article and its images belong to the publisher. Summary, key facts and assessment above are AI-written from the article and can be wrong.